A Song for Mama’s Milk: April Carnival of Breastfeeding

Welcome Carnival of Breastfeeding readers! This month’s theme was “Extended Nursing.” This is an older post that I’d written on the subject but it is still applicable.  Be sure to check out the links to all of the other participants and their thoughts about nursing toddlers at the end of this post. Enjoy and Happy Reading!! – Karianna

The other day, The Mister and I stumbled across the movie “Grown Ups.” What struck me about this movie was not that it was a mindless comedy with a revelation-for-the-good-of-the-family at the end, but that it featured a four-year-old nursing. As I am watching, I am thinking, “This could be fantastic! The beginnings of normalizing extended breastfeeding.” Of course, I was sorely disappointed. The breastfeeding scenes, while few, were met with jokes and ridicule and one ill-mannered four-year-old, demanding “I WANT MOMMY’S MILK!” What?! Is it too much to expect that Hollywood would treat extended breastfeeding with courtesy and respect? I guess that it’s easier to make fun of it since every one else does.

I am the mother of two daughters, both of whom would qualify as “extended breastfeeders.” The Bear will be 4 in July and weaned at 30 months. The Dragonfly will be two in September and is very much in love with nursing. The girls tandem nursed until The Dragonfly was three months old. At that point, this mama was pretty much done with tandem nursing. I asked The Bear if she would mind if Mama’s Milk was only for the baby. She looked at me at said, “Sure! Can I have some yogurt please?” And with that, my nursing relationship with the Bear was complete and, to be honest, she was still just a baby in my eyes.

Breastfeeding is one of my most cherished parenting tools. What do I do if the Dragonfly falls and hurts herself? Nursing makes it all better. What if the Dragonfly is having a rough day? Let’s take a moment and nurse. How about this one? Mama is stressed out and kids are getting on her last nerve? Let’s stop, nurse and reconnect. What if she’s sick and can’t keep solids down? Breastmilk’s got it covered. How about those “picky eating” phases, do I reach for a nutritional supplement? Nope, breastmilk is all that we need. The life of a toddler is all about exploration and discovery. Sometimes that exploration can get overwhelming and discovery can consume many free moments in the day. Nursing allows time to rest and for your excitable toddler to just be a baby once again.

But, extended breastfeeding isn’t culturally accepted or the norm. Why is that? Why is a child considered young enough to breastfeed at five months but too old by nine months? Why do we pressure mothers to begin solid foods at 4 months even if baby is not showing readiness signs? Mothers who nurse past one year or even two years are accused of being too attached to their kids or even worse, abusing them. They are told that what they are doing is “gross” or “twisted” or that breastmilk doesn’t have any benefits past twelve months. Really? Is that where we are in the 21st Century?

One of my favorite moments during the day is when The Dragonfly comes up to me, and says “Muk, peas!” We sit down to nurse, with tickles and giggles to boot. Near the end, she stops, looks up at me and says emphatically, “Done!” Every time it makes me laugh and then she laughs and runs off to resume playing. There is nothing weird or strange about extended breastfeeding. To the child, it is just another way of knowing that they are loved. We may cluck out tongues or look disapprovingly at a toddler or preschooler walking around with a bottle or pacifier, but we don’t ever think that the parent is somehow hurting the child. Why wouldn’t the same hold true for the nursing relationship?

I just finished reading A Song for Nagasaki: The Story of Takashi Nagai by Paul Glynn and there is a moment in the book that really exemplifies the extended breastfeeding relationship. I will warn you though, it may make your eyes well up… especially if you are a parent. (Spoiler Alert! If you are currently reading the book or planning to, you might want to stop reading the blog here. This scene is toward the end of the book.) The book is a true story about a man and his family living in Nagasaki before, during and after the dropping of the A-bomb on the city. The narrator is a father, talking about his daughter, after the bomb killed his wife:

“It is nighttime, and I am in bed in the hut with four-year-old Kayano in my arms. She is drowsy and almost asleep but instinctively reaches under my shirt and takes hold of my nipple. With a shudder, she realizes it is not her mother’s breast, and that her mother has disappeared. Suddenly, she is awake and sobbing.”


Make sure to visit the other Carnival Participants!

Elita @ Blacktating: The Last Time That Never Was

Mama Poekie from Authentic Parenting: Extended Breastfeeding

Mama Alvina of Ahava & Amara Life Foundation: Breastfeeding Journey Continues

Diana Cassar-Uhl, IBCLC: Old enough to ask for it

Judy @ Mommy News Blog: My Favorite Moments

Tamara Reese @ Please Send Parenting Books: Extended Breastfeeding

Jenny @ Chronicles of a Nursing Mom: The Highs and Lows of Nursing a Toddler

Christina @ MFOM: Natural-Term Breastfeeding

Rebekah @ Momma’s Angel: My Sleep Breakthrough

Suzi @ Attachedattheboob: Why I love nursing a toddler

Claire @ The Adventures of Lactating Girl: My Hopes for Tandem Nursing

Elisa @ blissfulE: counter cultural: extended breastfeeding

Momma Jorje: Extended Breastfeeding, So Far!

Stephanie Precourt from Adventures in Babywearing: “Continued Breastfeeding”: straight from the mouths of babes

The Accidental Natural Mama: Nurse on, Mama

Sarah @ Reproductive Rites: Gratitude for extended breastfeeding

Nikki @ On Becoming Mommy: The Little Things

Dr. Sarah @ Good Enough Mum: Breastfeeding for longer than a year: myths, facts and what the research really shows

Amy @ WIC City: (Extended) Breastfeeding as Mothering

The Artsy Mama: Why Nurse a Toddler?

Christina @ The Milk Mama: The best thing about breastfeeding

TopHat @ the bee in your bonnet: From the Mouths of Babes

Beth @ Bethstedman.com: Extended Breastfeeding: To Wean Or Not To Wean

Callista @ Callista’s Ramblings:  Pressure To Stop Breastfeeding

Amanda @ Postilius: Nursing My Toddler Keeps My Baby Close

Sheryl @ Little Snowflakes: Tandem Nursing- The Good, The Bad and The Ugly

Zoie @ Touchstone Z: Breastfeeding Flavors

Lauren @ Hobo Mama: Same old, same old: Extended breastfeeding

Tanya @ Motherwear Breastfeeding Blog: Six misconceptions about extended breastfeeding

Jona (Breastfeedingtwins.org): Breastfeeding Older Twins

Motherlove Herbal Company: Five reasons to love nursing a toddler

Pax Christi!



Filed under breastfeeding, family, life, mothering, wednesday

22 responses to “A Song for Mama’s Milk: April Carnival of Breastfeeding

  1. The pacifier/stroller thing is so strange to me. Rush the baby to independence with sleep training, but then let them ride in a stroller and suck on a pacifier until age 5 (or beyond!). But breastfeeding past 6 months is weird?

  2. Wow that quote from the book makes me really sad and makes me want to go wake up my baby and nurse 😦

  3. Pingback: My Sleep Breakthrough-Momma's Angel

  4. Pingback: My Favorite Moments «Mommy News and Views Blog

  5. Pingback: The Little Things « On Becoming Mommy

  6. Pingback: Natural-term breastfeeding « Massachusetts Friends of Midwives Blog

  7. Pingback: Tandem Nursing – The Good, The Bad and The Ugly | Little Snowflakes

  8. I am not too proud to say that, this was once me saying “I can’t imagine nursing my child when they can ask for it.” I just kept imagining me being somewhere in public and my child screaming to me that she wants to nurse and pulls out my breast herself. But now I know better and when you know better you do better.

  9. Thanks for this post, Karianna! It is wonderful to read your story and by sharing it, I believe you’ve helped to validate the biologically normal behavior of breastfeeding beyond infancy; if enough of us do that, ultimately, the biological norm will become the cultural norm.

  10. theadventuresoflactatinggirl

    Oh my goodness that quote at the end made me want to cry. It’s so true that there isn’t an age where nursing suddenly becomes bad to do. Nursing is always great and I love reconnecting with Peanut throughout the day.

    Also, I love your names for your kids. Peanut is my daughter’s nickname because elephants are “her animal.” I don’t know why, but I decided to give all my kids animals that are their own. Peanut’s room is decorated in elephants. 😛

  11. It’s so cute that your daughter says “done!” at the end of a nursing session.

  12. Pingback: The best thing about breastfeeding – The Milk Mama

  13. Pingback: Breastfeeding Older Twins :: Breastfeeding Twins

  14. Pingback: Gratitude for extended breastfeeding | Reproductive Rites

  15. Pingback: Breastfeeding Flavors « TouchstoneZ

  16. Pingback: Five reasons to love nursing a toddler | Motherlove Herbal Company Breastfeeding Blog and Podcasts

  17. I was so dissapointed in the treatment of extended nursing in that movie, too. I don’t think it did extended nursers any favorites. That passage from the book was so moving–my eyes did well up. Wow. Thanks for the thoughtful post 🙂

  18. Pingback: My Hopes For Tandem Nursing « The Adventures of Lactating Girl

  19. Thanks for sharing your story– and so beautifully! It’s amazing how very little the general public knows about extended breastfeeding, and the mass media and Hollywood definitely don’t make things any better.

    And, what an extremely powerful ending quote! Especially to the breastfeeding mom! As my first son is approaching his first birthday next week, I’ve been thinking more and more about weaning. That quote makes me never want to let go!

  20. This is a great post for the breastfeeding carnival. I remember hearing about that movie and thinking I’d like to see it. Then I saw a preview where they made fun of breastfeeding and I was so mad. I won’t be seeing that movie ever now (for which my husband is probably eternally grateful to avoid my rant)

    That quote totally got me weepy, too. It is so bittersweet as they begin to no longer need the solace of breastfeeding. Mine are still breastfeeding, but the two oldest skip days here and there. So, it’s coming. I doubt I’ll even realize when done actually happens until long after.

  21. Pingback: Old enough to ask for it « normal, like breathing

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s